Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future
Without rights, NM’s rivers can come up empty
Season 6 Episode 15 | 5m 32sVideo has Closed Captions
New Mexico rivers lack rights to their own waters and people are unwilling to share.
In NM, rivers lack rights to their own waters, which mean that when dry times strike—or people are unwilling to share—rivers run dry. “Water in New Mexico is managed on what's called the priority administration system, it's a system of extraction,” says Paul Tashjian with Audubon Southwest. There are ways to protect rivers that NM can and should explore in coming legislative sessions.
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future is a local public television program presented by NMPBS
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future
Without rights, NM’s rivers can come up empty
Season 6 Episode 15 | 5m 32sVideo has Closed Captions
In NM, rivers lack rights to their own waters, which mean that when dry times strike—or people are unwilling to share—rivers run dry. “Water in New Mexico is managed on what's called the priority administration system, it's a system of extraction,” says Paul Tashjian with Audubon Southwest. There are ways to protect rivers that NM can and should explore in coming legislative sessions.
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship<sub>>> Laura: FOR DECADES, THE RIO<br />GRANDE DOWNSTREAM OF</sub> <sub>ALBUQUERQUE HAS DRIED DURING<br />IRRIGATION SEASON.</sub> <sub>NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE PAY<br />ATTENTION TO THAT.</sub> <sub>BUT, THIS SUMMER IN JULY, THE<br />DRYING MARCHED UPSTREAM INTO</sub> <sub>ALBUQUERQUE.<br />AND PEOPLE NOTICED.</sub> <sub>WHAT MOST PEOPLE PROBABLY<br />DON'T REALIZE IS RIVERS IN NEW</sub> <sub>MEXICO DON'T HAVE RIGHTS TO<br />THEIR OWN WATERS SO THE WATER</sub> <sub>YOU SEE FLOWING PAST IT IS ALL<br />MEANT FOR SOMEONE ELSE</sub> <sub>DOWNSTREAM.<br />AND SOMETIMES WHAT THAT MEANS</sub> <sub>IS THERE IS NOT ENOUGH WATER<br />LEFT FOR THE RIVER ITSELF AND</sub> <sub>THE SPECIES THAT RELY UPON IT.<br />PAUL TASHJIAN IS DIRECTOR OF</sub> <sub>FRESH WATER CONSERVATION FOR<br />AUDUBON SOUTHWEST.</sub> <sub>KEEPING WATER IN RIVERS IS<br />SOMETHING HE THINKS ABOUT A</sub> <sub>LOT.<br />>> Tashjian: IN NEW MEXICO</sub> <sub>LIKE MANY WESTERN STATES,<br />THERE ARE NO INHERENT RIGHTS</sub> <sub>OR CLAIMS THAT RIVERS HAVE ON<br />THEIR WATER.</sub> <sub>WATER IN NEW MEXICO IS MANAGED<br />ON WHAT IS CALLED THE PRIORITY</sub> <sub>ADMINISTRATION SYSTEM AND THIS<br />IS LIKE MOST OTHER WESTERN</sub> <sub>STATES MANAGED ON A SIMILAR<br />SYSTEM.</sub> <sub>IT IS A SYSTEM OF EXTRACTION.<br />IT IS A WINNER-TAKE-ALL KIND</sub> <sub>OF SYSTEM AND HOW IT WORKS IS<br />THAT PERMITS ARE ISSUED FOR</sub> <sub>WATER RIGHT USERS UNTIL THERE<br />IS NO WATER LEFT.</sub> <sub>>> Laura: IN NEW MEXICO WHEN<br />DRY TIMES STRIKE, PEOPLE WITH</sub> <sub>THE OLDEST WATER RIGHTS,<br />SENIOR WATER RIGHTS, GET WATER</sub> <sub>FIRST.<br />AND UNLESS PEOPLE DECIDE TO</sub> <sub>SHARE SHORTAGES, JUNIOR OR<br />NEWER WATER RIGHTS CAN GET</sub> <sub>CUT.<br />THE OLDEST USERS, THE RIVERS</sub> <sub>THEMSELVES, THEIR ECOSYSTEMS,<br />THEIR WILDLIFE, THEY CAN BE</sub> <sub>LEFT WITH NOTHING.<br />>> Tashjian: THESE WATER RIGHT</sub> <sub>ISSUES WERE ISSUED DURING<br />WETTER TIMES UNDER THIS MODEL</sub> <sub>OF PRIOR APPROPRIATIONS WHERE<br />THERE ARE MORE WATER RIGHT</sub> <sub>PERMITS THAN THERE IS WATER IN<br />THE SYSTEM.</sub> <sub>THAT WAS BEFORE WE REALLY<br />STARTED TO SEE THE IMPACT OF</sub> <sub>CLIMATE CHANGE.<br />>> Laura: IT IS CLEAR DRY</sub> <sub>RIVERBEDS ARE BAD FOR FISH,</sub> <sub>COTTONWOODS FOREST, ALL THE<br />SPECIES INCLUDING HUMANS WHO</sub> <sub>RELY ON THEM.<br />>> Tashjian: DRY RIVERS ARE</sub> <sub>NOT GOOD FOR WATER MANAGEMENT<br />ITSELF.</sub> <sub>JUST TO MOVE WATER DOWN TO<br />FARMERS DOWNSTREAM OR BE</sub> <sub>MOVING WATER FOR DELIVERING IT<br />TO OUR NEIGHBORING STATES LIKE</sub> <sub>TEXAS, HAVING A DRY RIVER IS<br />NOT AN EFFICIENT WAY OR</sub> <sub>EFFECTIVE WAY TO MOVE WATER.<br />ACROSS THE BOARD, DRY RIVERS</sub> <sub>ARE DETRIMENTAL.<br />>> Laura: THERE ARE WAYS TO</sub> <sub>CHANGE THIS.<br />>> Tashjian: NEW MEXICO HAS</sub> <sub>DEVELOPED TOOLS TO KEEP WATER<br />IN THE RIVERS WITHIN THE WATER</sub> <sub>RIGHTS SYSTEM AND I THINK IT<br />IS REALLY IMPORTANT.</sub> <sub>I CRITICIZE THE PRIORITY<br />ADMINISTRATION SYSTEM BUT TO</sub> <sub>DISMANTLE IT ISN'T FEASIBLE.<br />>> Laura: WE HAVE THE</sub> <sub>STRATEGIC WATER RESERVE USED<br />TO KEEP WATER IN RIVERS FOR</sub> <sub>RARE ANIMALS PROTECTED UNDER<br />THE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT.</sub> <sub>FISH LIKE THE RIO GRANDE<br />SILVERY MINNOW, THE PECOS</sub> <sub>BLUNT-NOSE SHINER AND THE PIKE<br />MINNOW IN THE SAN JUAN RIVER.</sub> <sub>TO HELP THOSE SPECIES THE<br />STATE CAN LEASE WATER FROM</sub> <sub>WILLING FARMERS.<br />>> Tashjian: ANOTHER TOOL IS</sub> <sub>THIS THING CALLED DYNAMIC<br />WATER LEASING.</sub> <sub>IT IS SORT OF A NEWER TOOL<br />DEVELOPED BY IRRIGATION</sub> <sub>DISTRICTS, ONE WHERE<br />IRRIGATION DISTRICTS</sub> <sub>THEMSELVES ARE LEASING WATER<br />FROM WILLING LESSEES AND PUT</sub> <sub>INTO A SIMILAR KIND OF BANK<br />AND STORED AND USED FOR</sub> <sub>ENVIRONMENTAL PURPOSES.<br />>> Laura: THERE IS SO MUCH</sub> <sub>MORE TO DO.<br />>> Tashjian: WE ARE THE ONLY</sub> <sub>WESTERN STATE THAT DOESN'T<br />HAVE AN ENVIRONMENTAL FLOW</sub> <sub>PROGRAM AND IT HAS BEEN TALKED<br />ABOUT FOR A LONG TIME.</sub> <sub>WHAT AN ENVIRONMENTAL FLOW<br />PROGRAM DOES IS IT USES THE</sub> <sub>TOOLS THAT ARE TALKED ABOUT IN<br />OTHER TOOLS LOCALLY TO TRY TO</sub> <sub>FIND CREATIVE SOLUTIONS AND IT<br />REALLY SHIFTS THE GAME, SHIFTS</sub> <sub>IT FROM ONE WHERE YOU'RE<br />MANAGING FOR ENDANGERED</sub> <sub>SPECIES AND IT IS OUT OF FEAR<br />OF LITIGATION.</sub> <sub>IT LEADS TO KIND OF EDGY<br />MANAGEMENT AND I HAVE SEEN IT.</sub> <sub>BUT IF YOU SHIFT IT TO WHAT DO<br />LOCAL COMMUNITIES WANT?</sub> <sub>WHAT IS IMPORTANT?<br />WHAT TOOLS WORK IN THAT LOCAL</sub> <sub>COMMUNITY.<br />IT IS A MUCH DIFFERENT WAY OF</sub> <sub>MANAGING A SYSTEM.<br />I THINK THAT IS REALLY</sub> <sub>IMPORTANT.<br />ENDANGERED SPECIES ARE</sub> <sub>CRITICAL AND IMPORTANT, BUT<br />WHEN YOU'RE DEALING WITH</sub> <sub>ENDANGERED SPECIES, YOU'RE<br />ALREADY AT A CRISIS POINT.</sub> <sub>>> Laura: ONCE THE RIVER DRIES<br />AND DRIES THE NEXT YEAR AND</sub> <sub>DRIES AGAIN, WE GET USED TO<br />THAT.</sub> <sub>WE ACCEPT DRY OR BROKEN RIVERS<br />AS NORMAL.</sub> <sub>WE EVEN STOP REMEMBERING, STOP<br />TELLING STORIES ABOUT WHAT A</sub> <sub>LIVING RIVER WAS LIKE.<br />>> Tashjian: EL PASO IS PRETTY</sub> <sub>REMARKABLE IF YOU HAVE EVER<br />BEEN DOWN THERE.</sub> <sub>IT IS BASICALLY A LARGE<br />CONCRETE CHANNEL, WITH MAYBE A</sub> <sub>THREAD OF LEFT-OVER SEWAGE<br />WATER OR SOMETHING</sub> <sub>RUNNING IT<br />IN.</sub> <sub>IT IS REALLY DEGRADING AND NO<br />CORRIDOR OF TREES AROUND IT.</sub> <sub>IT IS JUST A FUTURISTIC,<br />CONCRETE, POST APOCALYPSE</sub> <sub>DITCH.<br />VERSUS HERE, YOU KNOW, WE HAVE</sub> <sub>A CORRIDOR OF COTTONWOOD AND<br />WILLOW TREES AND GRASSLAND AND</sub> <sub>A FLOWING RIVER.<br />IT IS QUITE DIFFERENT.</sub> <sub>HARD TO GO BACK.<br />YOU CAN'T SORT OF GO BACK</sub> <sub>TO -- A PLACE LIKE EL PASO,<br />YOU CAN'T ALL OF A SUDDEN</sub> <sub>RESTORE THAT RIVER DOWN THERE.<br />ONCE IT IS GONE.</sub> <sub>IT IS GONE.<br />>> Laura: IN NEW MEXICO OUR</sub> <sub>RIVERS HAVE TAKEN CARE OF US<br />FOR CENTURIES, FOREVER AND IF</sub> <sub>WE WANT TO KEEP THEM, IT IS<br />TIME FOR US TO BE GIVING BACK.</sub> <sub>FOR OUR LAND AND NEW MEXICO<br />IN FOCUS, I AM LAURA PASKUS.</sub>
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future is a local public television program presented by NMPBS